She was a sickly newborn who many believed wouldnt live past the age of one, but she did. Source: Fayetteville Police Department. He has been a guest speaker on numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author. She had a fracture to part of her hyoid bone and there was some soft tissue damage near the right side of the hyoid, but her hyoid was not fully broken. In the words of Megan Oxendines sister, Khelia Oxendine. system, without permission from Dr. Maurice Godwin. She was only in town a few days when on the 5th, she texted her mom around 11:30 AM to tell her that shed been running errands for about an hour. 339 Vanstory St. was shot to death as he stepped from his car at his home on Nov. 14, 1993 Nathan Turner, 14, shot. 1995. Oct. 5, 1990 Evelyn Huggins, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Unsolved Homicide - Ernesto Allen Unsolved Homicide - Sherry Alston Unsolved Homicide - Crystal Baker Unsolved Homicide - David Bullock North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation2023, North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation. She had been last seen at her parents' residence earlierthat Sunday morning. The murders remain unsolved. When investigators checked Wileys apartment, there were no signs of foul play. July 17, 2004 Miguel Sandoval, unknown age, handgun. The officers showed up at the little blue house with boarded up windows and upon entering the house found that there were still pieces of furniture left behind. Then on April 18, 2017, her body was found dead in the TV cabinet of an abandoned home at 505 Peachtree Street. When Rhonda Jones body was found, Megan was interviewed by the local news. In the end, Wheelers testimony played a role in getting Penn acquitted. One of his previous residences was also near a soccer field where one of the victims, Elizabeth Smallwood, was found. The fact that we have consulted with so many different departments. After a pillow was put over Wheelers head, one of the assailants fired a shot at him, but the bullet only grazed Wheelers ear, and he survived the attack. Its been theorized that Jones could have been killed while interrupting a drug transaction. Aug. 23, 1998 William Poe, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Last updated: May 11, 2009 And that is, our investigation, is to determine who did that. July 19, 2003 Turner Monroe, 20, handgun. The most intriguing clue, however, came from Wileys office typewriter. Dating back to the 1500's, here are seven of the most infamous unsolved mysteries in North Carolina. Weve had analysts working this. (Solved Serial Killer Samuel McCullum). The police also received heavy criticism for not investigating the crime scene properly. Found inside the home were her two daughters, ages 4 and 18 months. County, North Carolina. His body was 1. 40% of the countys population are members of the Lumbee Indian tribe (a state recognized tribe 2 of the 3 victims were Lumbee) and more than 68% of the population are American Indian, black, and hispanic. Because its obvious they didnt place themselves there. $5,000 REWARD for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person(s) responsible for thedeath of Deborah Gail Nunnery. The driver was investigated and was determined to be a friend who dropped her off at a different location. March 25, 1987 Curtis Matthews, unknown age, unknown cause of death. If you have information about this case, call the Windsor Police Department (252) 794-3111. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. him twice with a pistol. Her mom called her multiple times without getting an answer and by that night her calls were going straight to voicemail. May 21, 1993 Joann Harris, unknown age, shot. Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. Gregory Lockamy, 34, of Branson Street died from smoke inhalation in a fire I think that goes to show it doesnt matter what the label says. I think that goes to show it doesnt matter what the label says. We simply lack the necessary resources to properly investigate major crimes.. Were in a war when you think of homicide as a conflict, and we dont have enough boots on the ground, Hargrove said. The BAU said that this suspect may have left the community after the murders and if they didnt leave they likely changed their behavior or MO. Nimocks Ave. died a week after being found with gunshot wounds on Sept. 27, 1987 When OMaras vehicle was discovered at the service area, the nozzle from the gas pump was still in his tank. However, because the area is small and people know each other, people in the area knew who the body in the trash can was. These cookies do not store any personal information. Both the police and Megans mom felt that Megan knew more than she was telling. She also created a group called Shatter the Silence that started as a Facebook group in 2018 and is now working on getting nonprofit status. Their cases have never been completely explained. April 18, 1983 Ronnie Wayne Dickerson, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Megan had prostitution charges that were pending in Robeson County and had a court date in July of 2017. He was known for rigidly enforcing Prohibition laws and being one of the few honest cops in the area. While Megan was also naked, she was lying on top of her shirt. One focus of the investigation was the description of the vehicle driven by the suspect. Rhonda Jones originally wasnt from Lumberton either. Aint no one paying me to be a private investigator, but we aint going to stop.. After an intensive search, her body was located the following day in a drainage ditch next to a farm road approximately three miles from where Brittany was last seen alive. from a beating in his apartment at 913 Willow St. Ann Elizabeth Smith, 62, of Chase Street was killed by shots fired into her Im so tired. GIBSON, Jose Luis & Alonso A 9 year old leaves her house in the middle of the night and disappeared. In the relatively small town of Lumberton, North Carolina women have been turning up dead without an explanation and without a suspect. Inside the cabinet was a nude and decomposing body that had been covered by a blanket. He had been beaten and shot in the head four times. A case is defined as cleared when an arrest is made or there is an exception, such as a suspected killer being dead or incarcerated for another crime. She had been to rehab and spent some time in prison in North Carolina. Cumberland County Sheriff's Office. March 1, 1979 Brenda Covington, unknown age, screwdriver. B Street on Oct. 28, 1985. Drive was shot to death in the 2300 block of Murchison Road on Jan. 13, 1990. Cynthia was 41-years-old in 2017 (making her about 44-45 now). Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Thirty-five-year-old Jackie Thorpe was the next victim reported missing, and she was quickly found on August 17th near the Seven Bridges Road. Maybe the police grasped for straws when coming up with evidence to link Pittman to the crimes because they had no other suspects and wanted to resolve the matter in any way they could. We have many Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. July 5, 1999 Maricia Rice, 30, handgun. Feel free to contact him here. June 6, 1987 Eric Martineves, unknown age, unknown cause of death. William McKoy, 52, of 418-A Vanstory deliberately started on Nov. 24, 1991. May 7, 2019 Read More. 2002 Rita Wortham, unknown age, unknown cause of death. While researching the Coniff case for his master's thesis, Bamonte made some surprising discoveries. The caller spoke in hushed tones and identified herself as his mother-in-law, Virginia Durham. Because of a lack of proof, however, it still begs the question: Was Antwan Pittman really responsible for the deaths of all of these women? Jimmie Riddle, 24, a resident of a mobile home park off Country Club Drive, June 10, 1979 Earnest Garrett, unknown age, unknown cause of death. She was seen by at least one witness getting into a brown Buick down the street from her moms house on East 9th Street. Toxicology showed that Christina had cocaine in her system as well as nerve medication and nicotine. May 10, 1995 Andrea Patterson, 18, unknown cause of death. According to her family, she was a smart and spunky free spirit who enjoyed having fun and spending time with loved ones. Nov. 18, 1977 Johnny Strickland, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Blandenboro Fire Poltergeist, Bladenboro, 1932 Good Reads Mrs. Charles Williamson was just an ordinary housewife until one day her dress unexplainably caught fire. Area: 701 North Tryon Street, #413 . plans and enthusiasm Unsolved Homicide. Four years. I know I also speak for the entire Watauga County community when I say that we will never forget to keep the Durham family in our thoughts and prayers, he added. From the looks of it, his body hadnt, EARLY LIFE: Katherine Ktie Memory Jones was born in Asheville, North Carolina on December 19, 1989. However, they never got a chance to arrest and charge him for his crimes. Cynthia has black/brown hair and brown eyes and is part of the Lumbee tribe. In the summer, when there's no football or basketball, I like to read about unsolved NC murders. Only 2 weeks after her television interview, Megan was attacked. Wiley even claimed he had been working on a novel, but investigators could never find any manuscript for it. April 4, 1979 Loureen Hassell, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Older Unsolved Homicide Cold Cases. Some of the most infamous North Carolina murders that remain unsolved include the 1998 abduction and murder of Brittany Locklear, the 1971 double murder of Patricia Mann and Jesse McBane, as well as many well-known disappearances throughout North Carolina. Your chances of being raped, assaulted, or killed were 1 in 55 based on data from 2016. From the onset, she was someone who defied the odds. At approximately 2:30 AM on December 3, 1967, 22-year-old Herbert Schirmer was on a seemingly routine patrol near the town of Ashland, Nebraska, when he noticed a strange set of lights at a highway intersection. Since OMara spent a portion of his career taking down the Illinois mafia, one theory was that his death was a revenge killing. Oct. 11, 1988 David Porter, 29, shot. On the evening of March 28, Gainor left the police station after receiving a phone call. She grew up in Pembroke only 12 miles from Lumberton with her 2 sisters. Gillian, this was so interesting! These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. She had been hit in the head with a blunt object. The State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) Cold Case Investigation Team (CCIT) was founded in 2020. All three deaths were ruled to be suicides, even though there was no gun found at one of the scenes! Im not giving up. March 2, 1981 Janice Murphy Perry, unknown age, unknown cause of death. On Sunday,October 26, 1997 in the early morning hours, the body of Deborah Gail Nunnery was found on the roadwayof Underwood Road in the Snow Hill Community of Clinton. Her mom even thought that maybe Megan knew something about Rhondas murder, because after Rhonda died, Megan began acting differently. Another possible suspect was a former sheriffs officer who had recently been suspended by OMara for alcohol-related problems, but he was never interviewed and died six months later. He quickly returned to the police station and wrote in his logbook that he had seen a flying saucer. She is 57 and when she disappeared she weighed 140 lbs. Around 6 PM, Abbys mom called the police to report Abby missing. Her murder was unsolved until Sept. 16, 2021, when Chapel Hill police made an arrest in her case. As usual, in a small town, neighbors were being nosy trying to see why police were in their neighborhood. Unsolved Murder Files; Unsolved Mystery Files; Legend Files; Suggested Cases; The Investigators; Contributing. Oct. 3, 1980 Jefferson Dildy Jr., unknown age, unknown cause of death. Feb. 9, 1984 William McKoy, unknown age, handgun. Cold Case Files. Her remains had already decomposed, so not much information could be determined from them, but detectives believe that she was killed in her home and then transported to her burial site. When police spotted him in Greensboro in June 1985, they knew he was dangerous. Nov. 16, 1995 Ledell McGougan, 38, shot. For comparison, Pinehurst (1.5 hours away) the crime rate is 69.7% lower than the national rate and 72.5% lower than the North Carolina crime rate. COPYRIGHT: There were signs of trauma because her nose was broken and she had cuts and lacerations, but they were unable to determine if these were before or after death. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. found dead in his apartment on Feb. 17. Her body was found beneath a bridge on Russell Jan. 7, 1981 Roy Warren, unknown age, unknown cause of death. One of the most famous unsolved murders in North Carolina history was the 1967 strangulation of 19-year-old Brenda Joyce Holland outside Manteo. Davis, 81, who is believed to be the only surviving perpetrator, is in a correctional facility in Augusta, Georgia. Deborah would sometimes stay with her parents although she had her own residence in Quail Run Trailer Park in Roseboro. But, I will say I do believe that we have promising evidence. After Megans body was found, the Lumberton Police Department knew they needed help and called in the FBI. A CBS News analysis of the FBI data published last year found that murders of white victims were about 30% more likely to be solved than in cases with Hispanic victims, and about 50% more than when the victims were Black. Investigation prompts missing persons policy change, Effects linger from wrongful accusation in Norfolk, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Andre Patterson, 19, of 550 Horseshoe Road was shot once in the head on May Christinas autopsy showed no signs of trauma due to the decomposition of her body. Oct. 19, 1986 Nathaniel Marshall, unknown age, handgun. A North Carolina Bureau of Investigations (NCBI) special agent involved with the case said We cant really discuss any specific evidence that we have in the case. Sheriff John Montgomery said agents with the U.S. Marshal's . While decomposition made it impossible to see external signs of strangulation, internally there were some signs that could indicate she was strangled. They feel that this suspect may have told someone what they did and the confidante may have just brushed it off. In recent years, there have been allegations that the FBIs COINTELPRO program could have orchestrated the fake distress call in an attempt to discredit the Nation of Islam. We have given inadequate resources to properly fund local police departments. They proceeded to bring Schirmer aboard their spacecraft to communicate with him, claiming that they had been watching over the human race and were experimenting on them as part of a breeding analysis program. Nov. 7, 1994 Lawrence Tomlinson, 50, blunt force. He had been beaten. March 29, 1976 Nellie Hair, unknown age, blunt force. Republican Drive was killed by a bullet wound in the head. 14, 1982 Unknown female, unknown age, unknown cause of death. NCBI and the Lumberton police department have spent thousands of hours on these cases and said they have conducted more than 500 interviews and knocked on more than 800 doors during door-to-door canvassing. She was later diagnosed with bipolar and anxiety disorders. June 18, 1986 James Farmer, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Joshua Aaron Richardson, who was stationed at the Fort Bragg military base at the . While Joness death was initially believed to be a homicide, it was officially ruled a suicide two weeks later. A search turned up no trace of him until Halloween, when Mayfords body was discovered on the edge of a rural cornfield near Cahokia Creek. Rebecca Ann Thompson, 17, of 224 Megan wouldnt talk to the police though. Lumberton Unsolved Murders. Their deaths are listed with undetermined causes and havent been listed as homicide. Allison Jackson Foy. Rhonda Jones, Megan Oxendine, and Christina Bennett were 3 women dealing with their own demons when each of them were found dead. Sept. 26, 1991 Jimmy Riddle, 24, strangulation. The house was in an area that had been known for drugs and sex workers. I had to cremate my daughter. Shortly thereafter, Joness body was located near the lighthouse. After knocking, she entered the apartment to find her daughter dead. Skip main navigation-A A A + Our Organization . May 17, 1999 Waddell Hickson, 40, shot. We are still putting the same amount of effort into this. Megan called Rhonda, I aint never seen her act out or nothing. He had been beaten. Richard W. Northrup, 45, of Box 2852, The medical examiner wrote in her report that an instrument was used, but made no guesses about what it could be. near Greensboro and Hillsboro streets. June 3, 1997 Rachel McArthur, 29, blow to the head. The grisly triple murder of a man, a woman and their son found slain in a bathtub in 1972 has been solved 50 years later, thanks to information from a Georgia inmate, the Watauga County Sheriffs Office in Boone, North Carolina, announced. Multiple agencies, including the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, the Boone Police Department, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and the Appalachian State University Police Department, were also involved in the case. In April, the FBI raised the reward for information to $40,000 for information leading to a conviction.